Review of Nothing Ear (1) Headphones: Are They Worth ₹ 21,999 or Overhyped?

Review of Nothing Ear (1) Headphones: Are They Worth ₹ 21,999 or Overhyped?

In the realm of wireless earbuds, two standout contenders have emerged: the minimalistic and stylish Nothing Ear 1 and the Sony WF-1000XM5, known for their superior sound quality.

The Nothing Ear 1, with its transparent design, is a head-turner on crowded metros and bustling streets. Comfortable to wear, it fits well, although some users may find it less suitable during long sessions for certain ear shapes. The sound produced by the Nothing Ear 1 is clear, with a well-balanced bass that packs a slight punch. However, it falls short of being class-leading, with the music feeling somewhat confined within the earcups.

On the other hand, the Sony WF-1000XM5 delivers a more expansive and natural soundstage, allowing instruments to separate better and voices to sound more natural. The bass is more nimble and nuanced, and transient details are clearer, resulting in a richer and more realistic listening experience. The WF-1000XM5's sound allows the music to "breathe," offering a solidity and realism that the Nothing Ear 1 lacks.

The WF-1000XM5 also features a warm sound signature with boosted bass that can be fine-tuned via an app equalizer, accommodating various listening preferences. Its active noise cancellation (ANC) is highly effective, substantially reducing background noise and enhancing the immersive quality of the audio.

In terms of design, the Nothing Ear 1 showcases a minimalistic, futuristic look that could be considered a fashion statement. The materials used are light plastic with a matte finish. The Nothing Headphone 1 supports LDAC, USB-C audio, and a 3.5 mm jack, but requires toggling for multi-point pairing. The headphones are IPX4 rated for sweat resistance, but not dust resistant.

The Nothing Headphone 1 offers 42dB hybrid Active Noise Cancellation (ANC), but some users have reported slight creaking in the case, raising concerns about long-term durability. The call quality is acceptable, although some callers have reported instances of background leakage.

In comparison, the Sony WF-1000XM5 offers superior ANC and sound quality, making it a better choice for those prioritising sound quality and realistic audio reproduction in everyday use. The Nothing Ear 1, while stylish, may not rival brands like Sony or Bose in sound quality and ANC if not enhanced.

| Aspect | Nothing Ear 1 | Sony WF-1000XM5 | |-----------------------|----------------------------------------|--------------------------------------| | Soundstage | Small, compressed, less expansive | Spacious, natural, instruments well separated | | Bass | Muscular but somewhat shackled | Nimble, nuanced, boosted (adjustable)| | Midrange & Treble | Balanced but lacks airiness | Clear, detailed, natural | | Noise Cancellation | Good but less immersive | Superior ANC, significantly reduces background noise | | Customization | Limited | App-based EQ with presets |

In conclusion, while the Nothing Ear 1 offers a unique design and acceptable sound quality, the Sony WF-1000XM5 outperforms it noticeably in terms of sound quality and realistic audio reproduction. The Nothing Headphone 1 is suitable for urban commuters and individuals who appreciate style and design, but may not be the best choice for audiophiles or frequent travellers requiring very tight folding.

Smartphone users might consider the Nothing Ear 1 as a stylish accessory with decent sound quality, but for those seeking superior audio experiences, smartphones may pair well with the spacious and natural sounding Sony WF-1000XM5 wireless earbuds. In the realm of technology, the battle for the perfect wireless earbuds rages on, with both gadgets offering unique qualities.

Read also: